Court Rules in Favor of Nestlé Regarding Non-Disclosure of Slave and Child Labor

by

Editorial Policy

Published on

Last updated on

Photo by Pablo Merchán Montes

[A] putative class action lawsuit filed against Nestlé USA, Inc., Tomasella v. Nestlé, No. 18-cv-10269 (2019), alleged that Nestlé benefitted from unjust enrichment based on the company’s failure to disclose that its chocolate products likely contain cocoa beans farmed by child and slave labor from suppliers in Côte d’Ivoire. While Nestlé admits that some of its cocoa is sourced from the area, which has well-documented widespread practices of child and forced labor in the cocoa industry, a federal court in the District of Massachusetts found it was not deceptive for the company to omit those practices from its label.

Despite finding the plaintiff’s statements true, the court did not find Nestlé at fault. Nestlé’s omission of slave and child labor were not false statements, the court considered the practice a “pure omission,” meaning the company had said nothing in a circumstance that does not give any meaning to that silence. The ruling is consistent with several other cases brought under California’s consumer protection laws, which also found that businesses have no duty to disclose these types of supply chain labor practices.

Share This Article

Fresh Cup Staff

Join 7,000+ coffee pros and get top stories, deals, and other industry goodies in your inbox each week.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Other Articles You May Like

What Does Experimental Processing Mean for Farmers?

Experimental coffee processing methods are becoming increasingly popular in the specialty coffee world. But what does it mean for farmers to engage with the potential—and risk—of these methods?
by Veronica Blaine | May 22, 2024

In Colombia, Making Coffee Viable for Young Producers

The average age of coffee farmers in Colombia is 55. But there’s a thriving community of producers and changemakers making coffee viable and exciting for the next generation. 
by Nick Castellano | May 17, 2024

How Regenerative Agriculture Changed the Lives of Two Colombian Coffee Producers 

Across Colombia, producers are adapting and implementing new models for producing coffee—here’s how two producers used regenerative agriculture to improve their farms.
by Nick Castellano | May 1, 2024

The Accidental Coffee Farmer

When respected coffee farmer Andres Magaña Ortiz was deported after living in Hawaii for 30 years, his daughter Victoria had no choice but to take over.
by Fionn Pooler | March 13, 2024